Atom ResearchIndustry White Paper

The Future of Carbon Markets

Published by Atom Consulting

Why the shift to regulatory-grade credits will reshape supply, demand and capital flows across global carbon markets. The compliance-versus-voluntary binary is dissolving. What replaces it will determine who wins and who is left behind.

May 2026
35 min read
Topics:Carbon Markets · Regulatory Strategy · Capital Finance · CDR
Back to Home
Executive Summary

Global carbon markets are undergoing the most significant structural change since the Paris Agreement. The shift is not a move from voluntary to compliance markets. It is a deeper change — a separation of the market into regulatory-grade credits that can withstand the scrutiny of disclosure regimes, marketing restrictions and target-setting frameworks, and a residual long tail of credits that cannot.

This paper sets out Atom Research's view of how the market will reshape itself between 2026 and 2035, with a focus on what this means for project developers seeking finance, for buyers whose compliance and voluntary claims are subject to increasing legal and reputational scrutiny, and for the financial institutions that will be asked to bridge the two.

Regulatory and community pressure is pushing the carbon market toward credits that carry regulatory-grade attributes, regardless of whether those credits clear through a compliance or voluntary channel. The distinction between compliance and voluntary is dissolving; the distinction between integrity-assured and not is becoming absolute.

Six Key Findings

First.

The price signals are unambiguous. Generic voluntary avoidance credits have fallen below US$1 per tonne, while durable engineered removals trade between US$100 and US$1,000 per tonne. This is not a compliance-versus-voluntary gap. It is a gap between credits that survive regulatory scrutiny and credits that do not.

Second.

Six attributes now define whether a credit is regulatory-grade: governance under a CCP-eligible programme, host-country authorisation with corresponding adjustment, permanence classification, vintage currency, independent rating and jurisdictional eligibility. Credits carrying all six command premiums of 3–10x over generic equivalents. Credits carrying none are becoming structurally unsaleable.

Third.

Time and location are the next axes of differentiation. The GHG Protocol Scope 2 revision, SBTi V2's 24/7 Carbon-Free Energy requirement, and the EU data centre rating scheme together mean that by 2027–2028, large electricity buyers must demonstrate clean-energy procurement matched to consumption in the same hour and the same grid region.

Fourth.

The durable CDR market has critical single-buyer concentration risk. Microsoft accounted for 93 per cent of durable CDR purchased in 2025, and in April 2026 paused all future purchases. The next phase of the CDR market must be architected for multi-buyer, multi-use-case credit structures.

Fifth.

Airlines and hyperscale data centre operators will be the two most consequential demand archetypes through 2030. CORSIA Phase 1 compliance obligations are already binding. Data centres face triple pressure from surging AI energy demand, SBTi V2's hourly matching requirement, and the EU's forthcoming rating scheme.

Sixth.

The financing gap is the least discussed but most consequential feature of the emerging market. Conventional project finance struggles with long-dated, pay-on-delivery removal offtakes and host-country authorisation timing risk. Without financial innovation, the supply side cannot scale to meet regulatory demand.

<$1
Generic voluntary avoidance credit price per tonne, March 2025
Ecosystem Marketplace, 2025
$349
Average durable engineered removal price per tonne; leading projects >$500
Market data, 2025
3–10×
Price premium for credits carrying all six regulatory-grade attributes
Atom Research, 2026
93%
Share of durable CDR purchased in 2025 accounted for by Microsoft — paused April 2026
Heatmap News, 2026

1. Carbon Markets Are No Longer What They Were

For two decades, the global carbon market was described in binary terms: a compliance market in which regulated emitters surrendered government-issued allowances, and a voluntary market in which companies bought project-based credits for corporate climate claims. That binary no longer describes the market in 2026.

Consider three data points from late 2025 and early 2026. EU Allowances reached €82.85 per tonne in December 2025, up 21.5 per cent year on year. Generic exchange-traded nature-based voluntary avoidance credits fell below US$1 per tonne in March 2025. Durable engineered removal credits — Direct Air Capture, enhanced weathering, geological biochar — traded between US$187 and US$349 per tonne on average, with leading projects commanding over US$500 per tonne.

The price range spans almost three orders of magnitude. It is tempting to describe this as a compliance-versus-voluntary divide. It is not. The gap between the highest-priced voluntary durable removal and the highest-priced compliance allowance is narrower than the gap between two voluntary credits for the same notional quantity of carbon. The market is saying something about what it values, and the compliance-versus-voluntary framing obscures the message.

Three Forces Reshaping the Market

The Disclosure Force
Mandatory disclosure. The EU's CSRD/ESRS regime requires large European companies to report gross emissions separately from offsets — they cannot be netted against targets. Every credit purchased must be disclosed with its methodology, quality standard, corresponding-adjustment status and geographic origin. By 2027, every large company in every major economy will be disclosing credit quality in an audited context. Similar regimes are in force in the UK, Australia, Japan, Hong Kong and Singapore.
The Marketing-Restriction Force
Marketing restrictions. From 27 September 2026, the EU's Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition Directive prohibits product-level claims of climate neutrality based on offsetting. The prohibition is strict liability. German, French, Swiss and Dutch courts have already struck down "climate neutral" flight and fuel claims. The entire business case for cheap, high-volume, low-integrity credits sold to underwrite "carbon neutral" product labels has been regulated out of existence in Europe and is under threat elsewhere.
The Target-Setting Force
Private-sector target-setting convergence. SBTi V2, governing target-setting for over 11,000 companies, formalises carbon credits into an Ongoing Emissions Responsibility framework, mandates removals-only credits from 2035, and requires 41 per cent long-lived removals by 2050. Their combined effect is to segment the market by quality, permanence, authorisation and location in ways that were not true three years ago.
The Three-Lines Framework
Throughout this paper Atom Research uses a three-lines framework. Line 1 (The compliance cap): instruments priced by regulatory scarcity — EU, UK, California, China allowances. Not available for project developers to supply. Line 2 (The integrity line): compliance offsets, CORSIA CEEUs, ACCUs, A6.4ERs and CCP-labelled voluntary credits, priced primarily by quality and regulatory acceptance. Line 3 (The permanence line): durable removals priced on abatement cost curves, not market-clearing dynamics. When we say the market is reorganising around regulatory-grade attributes, we mean Line 2 and Line 3 are growing at the expense of the commodity voluntary market beneath Line 2.

2. The Global Market Architecture in 2026

According to the ICAP 2026 Status Report, 41 emissions trading systems are now in force worldwide, covering 26 per cent of global greenhouse gas emissions. ETS revenues reached nearly US$80 billion in 2025. Jurisdictions operating an ETS account for 63 per cent of global GDP and more than half the world's population.

41
Emissions trading systems in force worldwide as of 2026
ICAP Status Report, 2026
26%
Share of global GHG emissions covered by an ETS
ICAP, 2026
$80B
Collective ETS revenues in 2025
World Bank, 2025
63%
Share of global GDP in ETS jurisdictions
ICAP, 2026
CORSIA — The Only Global Compliance Market for Project Credits
The Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation is the only global sectoral compliance scheme entirely built on project-based offsets — there are no allowances. Phase 1 (2024–2026) covers 130 participating states. Phase 2 (2027+) becomes mandatory for essentially all ICAO member states. Baseline is 85 per cent of 2019 emissions. Phase 1 CEEUs must carry a host-country corresponding adjustment under Article 6. Without the Letter of Authorisation, the credit cannot be used for CORSIA compliance, regardless of the registry. For any developer targeting scale in compliance demand, CORSIA is where scale lives.

3. How Regulation Is Reshaping Demand

The regulatory landscape in 2025–2026 is doing three things simultaneously: separating gross emissions from offset accounting; creating compliance-grade pathways for high-integrity voluntary units; and shutting off the low-integrity end of the market via marketing restrictions and procurement standards. The cumulative effect is that regulators are not banning voluntary credits — they are forcing voluntary credits to be washed through integrity frameworks before they can be used for any publicly defensible claim.

CSRD and ESRS E1-7

The Omnibus I directive (February 2026) narrowed CSRD scope but left ESRS E1-7 — the carbon credit disclosure sub-standard — intact. Carbon credits cannot be deducted from Scope 1, 2 or 3 emissions. For every credit purchased, the company must disclose volume, project type, quality standard, share of EU-based projects, and whether it carries an Article 6 corresponding adjustment. That last clause does significant work: it makes CA status a mandatory disclosure field, creating an indirect premium for CA-bearing credits because buyers know they will have to answer for it under audit.

The EU Carbon Removal Certification Framework

Regulation (EU) 2024/3012 entered into force in December 2024. On 3 February 2026, the European Commission adopted delegated acts for three permanent removal pathways: DACCS, BioCCS and Biochar Carbon Removal. Projects could begin CRCF certification in early 2027, with first CRCF-labelled credits reaching registries in late 2027 or early 2028. The most consequential provision: the European Commission must assess by July 2026 whether CRCF-certified removals can be integrated into the EU ETS. If admitted — likely no earlier than 2030 — this becomes the single largest structural demand event in the history of global carbon markets.

A Direct Warning to Developers
Renewable energy credits from mature grids cannot survive the additionality lens that every serious integrity framework now applies. Price signals have already communicated this; most developers have not. If your origination pipeline is dominated by grid-connected renewable energy methodologies in middle-income countries, it is already a stranded asset.

SBTi Corporate Net-Zero Standard V2

V2 is the most material change in voluntary-market structure in a decade. It replaces "Beyond Value Chain Mitigation" with Ongoing Emissions Responsibility (OER). From 2035, credits used for emissions responsibility must be removals, not avoidance. By 2050, at least 41 per cent of removals must be long-lived — storage horizons of centuries to millennia. And it proposes that removals used for corporate neutralisation shall not simultaneously count toward host-country NDCs. That "double-claiming" question is the single most important unresolved issue in the 2026 market.

4. The Regulatory-Grade Credit: Six Attributes That Define the New Quality Floor

A credit carrying all six attributes commands a price premium of 3–10× over a generic equivalent. A credit carrying none is becoming structurally unsaleable for any use that must survive the CSRD, ISSB, SBTi V2 or ECGT screens.

Attribute 1Programme Governance Under a CCP-Eligible Standard
Eight programmes are now CCP-eligible: Verra (VCS), Gold Standard, ACR, Climate Action Reserve, ART, Isometric and others. More than 36 methodologies are CCP-approved. CCP-approved categories saw prices rise ~35% in H2 2024. For any premium market, CCP approval is not optional — it is the entry ticket.
Attribute 2Host-Country Authorisation with Corresponding Adjustment
For any credit crossing a border into a compliance or disclosure use case — CORSIA, Singapore ICC, JCM, K-ETS, or SBTi V2-aligned voluntary claims — a Letter of Authorisation and corresponding adjustment are required. This prevents double counting. The absence of a LoA is now the single largest origination bottleneck in the market. Developers should treat host-country authorisation as a capital expenditure, not an administrative afterthought.
Attribute 3Permanence Classification
Short-lived removals (decadal) are suitable for biogenic neutralisation and contribution claims, but not for fossil-emission neutralisation under SBTi V2. Long-lived removals (DACCS, BioCCS, geological-storage biochar) are the only credits unambiguously fit for fossil-emission neutralisation. Avoidance credits are excluded from post-2035 SBTi V2 neutralisation entirely. Permanence must be designed in at project inception.
Attribute 4Vintage Currency and Methodology Version
CORSIA Phase 1 and Singapore ICC both require 2021 or later vintage. SBTi V2 and VCMI buyers specify recent vintages to match current emissions. A project using an older methodology version faces discounting — sometimes severe — regardless of the quality of the underlying activity. Re-verification and methodology upgrade are becoming routine operational requirements.
Attribute 5Independent Rating
The ICVCM's CCP assessment is at methodology level, not project level. BeZero Carbon, Sylvera and Calyx Global provide project-level ratings. Sylvera data shows highly-rated ARR credits trade above US$35/tonne while lower-rated equivalents trade below US$20 — a 50–100% premium. Sophisticated buyers now specify minimum rating thresholds in their procurement policies.
Attribute 6Jurisdictional Eligibility
A credit can be CCP-approved, authorised, durable, current vintage and highly rated — and still be ineligible for a specific use. CORSIA Phase 2 has methodology exclusions. CRCF requires EU location. Singapore ICC requires a bilateral implementation agreement. Credits with multiple eligibility labels command premiums for serving the broadest buyer base.

The Six Attributes in a Procurement Matrix

Buyer ArchetypeProgrammeAuthorisationPermanenceVintageRating
EU Corporate (CSRD)HighHighMediumMediumHigh
Airline (CORSIA)CriticalCriticalLow–MediumHighMedium
Hyperscaler (SBTi V2)HighMedium–HighCriticalMediumCritical
Asian Compliance (SG, KR, JP)HighCriticalLow–MediumHighMedium
Australian SafeguardMediumLow (domestic)MediumMediumMedium

5. Time and Location: The Next Axis of Differentiation

If integrity and permanence are the axes on which the market is segmenting today, time and location are the axes on which it will segment next. Three converging regulatory vectors together mean that by 2028, any large electricity consumer with a net-zero claim will face pressure to demonstrate that its clean-energy procurement is matched to consumption in both the same hour and the same grid region. Annual matching with generic certificates will no longer be defensible.

GHG Protocol Scope 2 Revision

Public consultation closed January 2026; final standard expected late 2027. Proposes hourly matching (RECs issued and redeemed for the same hour) and deliverability (purchase from generators that could physically deliver to the consumer's grid location). A German data centre can no longer cover its consumption with Norwegian hydro Guarantees of Origin.

SBTi V2 Hourly Matching

Mandates 100% low-carbon electricity by 2040, defined as hourly-matched and sourced from the same grid market. The cascading-alignment mechanism means this requirement propagates up and down value chains across all 11,000+ SBTi-validated companies.

EU Data Centre Rating Scheme

The recast Energy Efficiency Directive mandates every EU data centre above 500 kW to report PUE, WUE, Energy Reuse Factor and Renewable Energy Factor into a public European database. Once published, the REF becomes an auditable number — any claim that cannot survive hourly and deliverability scrutiny will be a reputational liability.

The Microsoft pause is not a market failure. It is the market finally pricing in single-buyer concentration risk that should have been priced three years ago. The next phase of the durable CDR market must be architected for multi-buyer, multi-use-case credit structures — an architecture the existing voluntary-market infrastructure does not yet adequately support.

6. Eight Pathways for Credit Generation

We identify eight distinct pathways positioned to win regulatory-grade demand through 2035. Developers whose pipelines are dominated by project-level avoided-deforestation REDD+ or grid-connected renewable energy in mature markets are, in our view, already in structural decline.

PathwayPrimary BuyerIndicative PriceCritical Success Factor
A. EU-located durable CDREU corporates, hyperscalers€80–€400/tCO₂eCRCF certification; geological storage access
B. Host-country authorised A6 creditsAirlines (CORSIA), Singapore ICC$15–$40/tCO₂eOperational Letter of Authorisation in host country
C. Jurisdictional REDD+BVCM / OER contribution buyers, LEAF$10–$30/tCO₂eJurisdictional scale; governance credibility
D. CRCF Carbon FarmingEU corporates, CAP buyers€15–€60/tCO₂eMethodology alignment with delegated acts (late 2026)
E. Non-EU engineered removalsUS hyperscalers, Frontier, Japan/Korea$100–$1,000+/tCO₂eMulti-buyer offtake architecture; technology scale-up
F. Hourly-matched EACsHyperscale data centres (all regions)2–5× standard EACsSame-grid-region capacity + firming / storage
G. Commodity EACsIndustrials, data centre constructionEmergingIndustrial partnership; SBTi V2 activity-pool alignment
H. Dual-use credits (multi-eligibility)Multi-segment buyers, Asian compliance$20–$45/tCO₂eSimultaneous CCP + CORSIA + Singapore eligibility

No single developer should attempt all eight pathways — the origination disciplines are different enough that specialisation beats generalism. Across all eight, the common theme is that capital intensity and time-to-revenue have both increased relative to the legacy voluntary market.

7. The Capital Challenge

The mismatch between the capital structures the new pathways require and the financing instruments conventionally available is the reason the supply side is not currently scaling to meet the regulatory demand described in this paper. Absent financial innovation, the market will arrive "regulatorially" but will not arrive commercially. The demand curve will be there. The supply curve will not catch up.

Current Financing Instruments — Strengths and Gaps
InstrumentWhat it does wellWhere it falls short
Corporate offtake (pay-on-delivery)Revenue visibility; enables development capital raisingConcentrates counterparty risk; doesn't fund capex; single-buyer exposure
Project equityFlexible; bears technology and delivery riskExpensive; limited pool of investors with CDR mandates
Climate-focused VC / growth equitySupports technology scale-upExit horizons too short; doesn't address authorisation or permanence risk
Sovereign / DFI financePolitical risk mitigation; concessional pricingSlow deployment; limited mandate jurisdictions; doesn't serve engineered CDR
Grant programmes (EU Innovation Fund)De-risks first-of-a-kind capexNot scalable; jurisdictionally limited; no operating capital
Forward purchase clubs (Frontier, NextGen)Aggregates demand; catalyses early marketStill concentrated; opaque pricing; dependent on member commitment cycles

Four categories of financial innovation are needed: portfolio-level offtake aggregation from multiple buyers; authorisation risk insurance or guarantees (analogous to MIGA political risk instruments); hybrid debt/equity instruments for long-dated CDR that transition from equity-like capital during development to debt-like coupons once delivery is proven; and standardised secondary market infrastructure enabling more liquid secondary markets.

Where financial innovation is available, the market we describe is buildable. Where it is not, the supply-side bottleneck will throttle regulatory-grade credit availability, keeping prices elevated and creating material compliance risk for the demand side. The missing middle — institutional capital specifically architected for regulatory-grade credit origination — is the single largest opportunity in the carbon market today.

8. Applied Case: The Data Centre as the Archetypal Regulatory-Grade Buyer

Consider a new-build hyperscale data centre in Frankfurt, Germany. Installed IT power demand: 80 MW. Annual electricity consumption: 1.0 TWh. Construction-phase embedded emissions: approximately 900 kilotonnes of CO₂e over three years. The operator has SBTi-validated targets, is CSRD-scope from FY2027, and has 24/7 CFE aspirations for 2030.

Under the revised GHG Protocol Scope 2 rules, the operator cannot cover its 1 TWh load with annual-matched Norwegian hydro Guarantees of Origin. It needs hourly-matched renewable energy deliverable to the Frankfurt grid, combined with battery storage for dark/windless hours — plus ongoing removal credits from 2035 for any residual. In supply terms, this single site generates demand for approximately 500 kilotonnes per year of regulatory-grade credits at maturity: 200,000 tonnes of long-lived removals, 150,000 tonnes of short-lived nature-based removals, and 150,000 tonnes of contribution-style avoidance credits.

At a blended average of US$80 per tonne, that is US$40 million per year per site. Across a portfolio of 10–20 hyperscale sites, a single operator's procurement budget reaches hundreds of millions of dollars annually. The lesson from the Microsoft pause: no single developer should represent more than 20–25 per cent of supply to any single operator. Multi-buyer, multi-developer, multi-pathway architecture is now non-negotiable for both sides.

9. Eight Decision Points Through 2027

Every argument in this paper depends on how a specific set of regulatory and standard-setting decisions land over the next 18–24 months. Industry participants who approach these as "wait and see" will find themselves behind the curve.

Milestone 1
SBTi V2 Final StandardMid–Late 2026

Whether corresponding adjustments become a de facto requirement for voluntary removals used in SBTi-aligned neutralisation claims. Our view: SBTi V2 will finalise closer to the hawkish scenario for fossil-emission neutralisation, with transition provisions for existing state-backed projects.

Milestone 2
EU Commission CRCF/ETS AssessmentJuly 2026

Whether CRCF-certified removals can be surrendered against EU ETS obligations. Our view: a positive signal toward admission with cautious timeline, likely no admission before 2030, but the option value is material now.

Milestone 3
GHG Protocol Scope 2 Final StandardLate 2027

Whether hourly matching and deliverability become the global corporate accounting standard for electricity. Our view: hourly matching will land as a default requirement with phased implementation and thresholds for smaller reporters.

Milestone 4
EU Data Centre Energy Efficiency PackageQ2 2026

Introduction of a public rating scheme for EU data centres. Our view: will influence procurement behaviour quickly as operators compete on publicly disclosed REF and PUE figures.

Milestone 5
CORSIA Phase 2 Supply Ramp / First A6.4ERsThrough 2026–2027

Whether CORSIA Phase 2 has adequate eligible supply. Our view: supply remains tight through 2027; developers with authorisation-ready projects in qualifying host countries have pricing power that will not persist.

Milestone 6
ECGT Enforcement Commencement27 September 2026

Strict-liability enforcement of the ban on product-level climate-neutrality claims based on offsetting. Our view: uneven initially, concentrated in Germany, France and Netherlands — but the first high-profile enforcement cases will trigger broad corporate pullback.

Milestone 7
Microsoft CDR Purchase Resumption2026–2027

Whether and on what terms the single largest CDR buyer returns. Our view: Microsoft will resume but with tighter developer screening, harder pay-on-delivery terms, and multi-buyer consortium structures.

Milestone 8
CRCF Carbon Farming Delegated ActsLate 2026–2027

Operational rules for CRCF certification of EU agricultural soil carbon, agroforestry and peatland rewetting. Our view: strict permanence and additionality requirements; significant methodology turnover expected.

10. Conclusion: The Future of Carbon Markets

The global carbon market is not in crisis. It is in transition — toward a market architecture that is more demanding, more fragmented, more capital-intensive and ultimately more serious than the one it is replacing.

The compliance-versus-voluntary framing that dominated carbon market discourse for twenty years is now the wrong frame. The more important distinction is between credits that carry regulatory-grade attributes and credits that do not. A CCP-labelled, authorised, durable, current-vintage, independently-rated, jurisdictionally-eligible voluntary credit is, functionally, a compliance-grade asset. A generic voluntary credit without these attributes is increasingly unsaleable for any publicly defensible use.

The market has already priced this shift. The generic voluntary credit trading below US$1 while durable removals trade above US$300 is not a compliance-versus-voluntary divide. It is a regulatory-grade-versus-not divide. The market is saying, clearly, what it values.

The least-discussed feature of the emerging market is the financing gap. The eight pathways described in this paper cannot scale on the financing instruments available today. Portfolio-level offtake aggregation, authorisation risk coverage, hybrid debt/equity structures for long-dated CDR, and standardised secondary market infrastructure are all needed. This is the opportunity — and the obligation — for the financial industry.

About Atom Research
Atom Research develops financial architectures and market frameworks for carbon markets and adjacent climate asset classes. This paper is written for the financial industry and its clients on both sides of the market: project developers seeking capital; airlines, hyperscalers and corporates whose demand is increasingly constrained by regulation; and the investors, lenders and advisory firms that serve both. It takes positions. It names which pathways we think are winning and which are finished.

Disclosure & Notes

This paper represents the research and analytical perspective of Atom Research / Atom Consulting Limited. Market data is sourced from publicly referenced industry materials including ICAP, ICVCM, Ecosystem Marketplace, IATA, Abatable, Sylvera, BloombergNEF, World Bank and related market commentary. Nothing in this paper constitutes investment advice, financial product advice, or a solicitation to invest. All forward projections and regulatory outcome assessments carry inherent uncertainty; scenarios are presented to support decision-making, not as predictions. Published May 2026.